Discrimination against Romanians and Bulgarians - Public Policies Made by Citizens (Europe)

Human Rights: Discrimination against Romanians and Bulgarians

Posted by : Mihaela Dan
Country : Romania
Date : 18.05.2010
Profession : CONSULTING
From : PTIR
Target institution : European Parliament, European Commission
Problem status :

At the end of 2013, Bulgarians and Romanians will gain the same rights to work in the UK and other EU countries, as other EU citizens. In 2007, they gained the right to visa-free travel, when the two countries joined the EU. But there were temporary restrictions on the kind of jobs they could take. Employers had to apply for work permits and migrants for an "accession worker card". Low-skilled workers were restricted to existing quota schemes in the agricultural and food processing sectors. These restrictions will be dropped on 1 January 2014. Bulgarians and Romanians will also be entitled to claim the same benefits and NHS care as other EU citizens. Apart from Britain, eight countries have imposed restrictions of some kind on Romanians and Bulgarians, which will expire at the same time: Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Luxembourg, Malta, Spain, and The Netherlands. (Source: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-21523319).

Ministers from the UK for example, draw up plans to impose welfare restrictions when Romanians and Bulgarians are given full travel rights across the EU next year. Romanian and Bulgarian MEPs however, claimed they were being treated as "second-class Europeans" and Britain must act within EU law which says that Romanians and Bulgarians must be treated like all EU citizens from 2014. (Source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/feb/01/lib-dems-tories-romanians-bulgarians).

As we can see, Romanians and Bulgarians are seen in a very negative way by many other countries from Europe. This may happen because they don't know the traditions, culture and hospitality of the two countries and rely mostly on headline TV and Internet stories for information that present cases of felonies and misdemeanors.

Solutions received from citizens

Przemek Chądzyński, Poland, web developer (19.05.2010)

People are thinking using sterotypes - same way at Germany through many years people thought that guys from Poland always were drunken and thiefs; now it is changing;
I spent couple nice days at RO - and it was very good time. I met people who are great professionalist at theirs work.
From my point of view it not depend of yours activites inside country. You shoud "export" people who are great workers in many areas. It could be hard - becasue you need them in RO. But outside of PL minds started changing after opening the borders. When specialists started work in UK, Benelux, DE - then opinion about Polish workes and people at general changed.

iulia mariana condurache, Romania, student (18.05.2010)

It is right that we should promote better ours values, ours traditions, ours peoples, those who make honor to our contry. We can do that whit the help of the tourism, campains, change of experience whith schools and universities from other countries, internationals projects for youngs, theatres ans dansers company tours, romanian singer in toutnaments and other. Promote ourselfs!!

Ladanyi Emese, Romania, Coordonator Proiect (18.05.2010)

Romania, like many other European country is a multicultural one. And that is a good thing. The problem is us, Romanian citizens. We are not proud of us. We see and we publish (the press) only the bad things. We should try to build a good image for our country, for our people. But I don`t think that the press is guilty. They publish what the audience or the public ask for. And as I see, it is us, who want to see negative things. We are not proud of our values, even if we have them. Sad.

bodescu madalina, Romania, elev (18.05.2010)

Membrii UE trebuie sa inteleaga ca nu toti romanii sunt la fel,sa fib roman nu inseamna ca esti tigan sau cersetor. Consider ca statul roman ar trebui sa se implice mai mult in aceasta problema prin intensificarea controalelor vamale,printr-o campanie de informare in vederea estomparii emigratiei ilegale. Deasemenea,romanii din diaspora ar trebui sa le vorbeasca colegilor lor straini despre aceasta problema,explicandu
-le care sunt diferentele. Romanii trebuie sa invete sa fie mai nationalisti.

Elena Filip, Romania, student (18.05.2010)

I think that we should promote the tourism in Romania, because we have a lot of interesting places, where people can spend their vacations. This way, they can meet romanian people and they can see that we are not that bad.

iulia mariana condurache, Romania, student (18.05.2010)

Inainte de toate ar trebui trase la raspundere posturile Tv, radiourile internationale atunci cand exprimandu-se despre Romania si romani de multe ori fac greseli din necunoastere. Ceea ce apare in mass media e luat de bun, chiar daca informatiile sunt uneori eronate. Asadar mass media internationala ar trebui sa publice rectificari s sa publice in primul rand doar informatii verificate.

What is your solution?

Fields marked with * are mandatory.

Explain your solution: Please, be as brief and accurate as possible. This field is limited to 1500 characters. In case you need more space, publish a second solution idea. To be considered in the policy paper, your solution should meet the three criteria that form the mission of our project:

be feasible: this means that it can be accomplished by the existing organizations or with help from others.
be valuable: it should bring value to overseers, people in general or members of various communities.
be sustainable: it is likely to attract public support, authority and money from the political, social or business environments.

Your name: We publish your name to give you credit for your solution proposal and to promote you.

Your country: We publish your country to see how intercultural is the participation to solve this problem.

Your profession: We also publish your profession to give you credit.

Your education: We do not publish your education, but ask for it for our statistical purposes.

Your email: We do not publish this information. We keep it for our own records to stay in touch with you in case we need more information about your solution idea when we issue the policy paper.

Your phone number: We do not publish your phone number. We store it for our own records to communicate with you when issuing the policy paper, if needed.

Your webpage: This field is not mandatory. If you have a blog or an organization, you can promote it here. However, we will not accept websites that promote sex, violence, hatred or other inappropriate behavior.

Upload a photo of yourself

Upload a photo of yourself: This field is not mandatory. You can upload a square-sized photo of 80x80 pixels or higher. We want to promote you and give you credit for your solution idea(s). The supported formats are JPG, GIF and PNG.

The CAPTCHA Code: To avoid spam, type in the two words that show up in the CAPTCHA box.

Thank you for having the initiative to publish a solution to this problem on Public-Policies.EU, our citizen engagement platform! Your effort is making a great contribution to fulfilling our mission, that is engaging people in providing valuable, sustainable and feasible solutions to problems of public concern. With your example, we are closer to generating public policies made by citizens!

This website has been produced with the assistance of the European Union. The contents of this publication are the sole responsibility of SMART Development Center and can in no way reflect the views of the European Union.